STStratosGovernance diagnostic

KAZ / methodology v0.4.0

Kazakhstan

Cluster D: Electoral autocraciesmedium classification confidenceGenerated 2026-11-01

Within the electoral-autocracy cluster — where accountability infrastructure is by definition limited and within-cluster comparison should not be read as a judgement of the alternative, Kazakhstan is scored on 3 of five dimensions with currently available indicators. Relative strengths within its cluster: distributional reach.

Scored dimensions

3/5

Suppressed dimensions remain visible.

Data quality

73

Composite, 0-100.

Sources

3

undp_hdr, world_bank_wdi, world_bank_wgi

Peer set

22

Cluster D comparators.

Indicators

36

Raw series exposed below.

Interpretation

Diagnostic narrative

The narrative is template-generated from the measured scores, trajectories, confidence bands, and data limits. No free-form production LLM is used.

Headline assessment

Within the electoral-autocracy cluster — where accountability infrastructure is by definition limited and within-cluster comparison should not be read as a judgement of the alternative, Kazakhstan is scored on 3 of five dimensions with currently available indicators. Relative strengths within its cluster: distributional reach.

Strengths

Dimensions where the country outperforms its regime cluster on currently available indicators.

  • Distributional reach — z = +0.68 [+0.54, +0.81] (85th percentile within cluster, high coverage). Question: who benefits.

Gaps

No dimension falls below the gap threshold (z <= -0.5) on currently available indicators. Within-cluster performance is consistent across measured dimensions.

Trajectory

Trajectory over the most recent five-year window across 25 measured indicators: 5 improving, 0 declining, 20 stable. Direction is computed from the slope of the most recent five (or fewer) observations normalised against cluster variance; consistency reflects whether the change is monotonic.

  • wdi_life_expectancy: improving at +0.23 sd/yr (volatile, last observation 2024).
  • wdi_internet_users_pct: improving at +0.11 sd/yr (monotonic, last observation 2024).
  • wdi_internet_users_pct: improving at +0.11 sd/yr (monotonic, last observation 2024).
  • wgi_control_of_corruption: improving at +0.07 sd/yr (volatile, last observation 2024).
  • wgi_government_effectiveness: improving at +0.07 sd/yr (volatile, last observation 2024).
  • wdi_tax_revenue_pct_gdp: stable at +0.04 sd/yr (volatile, last observation 2023).

Constraints

Structural-constraint conditioning is implemented in stages. Phase 1 conditions on regime cluster only — the country is compared against its cluster peers, which controls implicitly for the structural inheritances that shape cluster membership. Geography, demographic structure, resource endowment, and historical institutional legacy are conditioned on explicitly in Phase 2. Electoral autocracies hold elections but not free and fair ones. Accountability infrastructure is scored on formal mechanisms here; the question of within-regime accountability (party discipline, succession norms) is largely invisible in current Stratos indicators and a known methodology gap.

  • Regime cluster: Electoral autocracies (D). Confidence: medium.
  • Classification rationale: Bootstrap (no V-Dem): negative VA, non-negative GE.

Data limits

Data quality and indicator coverage are reported as first-class outputs. The dashboard deliberately exposes coverage and confidence bands so users can judge whether a score is informative. Underlying sources: undp_hdr, world_bank_wdi, world_bank_wgi.

  • Execution capacity: moderate coverage (70% of catalogue indicators present).
  • Adaptive capacity: moderate coverage (60% of catalogue indicators present).
  • Conversion efficiency: insufficient indicators available for scoring.
  • Accountability infrastructure: insufficient indicators available for scoring.

Scores

Five dimensional scores

Point estimates use within-cluster z-scores. Positive values sit above the cluster mean by Stratos convention; indicators where lower is better are sign-flipped before aggregation.

Can the state do things

Execution capacity

-0.49

33th percentile

Moderate coverage

70% indicators

Uncertainty shown

CI [-0.95, -0.03]

Audit trail: 7 contributing indicators
IndicatorzYearSource
Government effectivenesswgi_government_effectiveness-1.022024world bank wgi
Regulatory qualitywgi_regulatory_quality-0.912024world bank wgi
Rule of lawwgi_rule_of_law-1.222024world bank wgi
Electricity access (% of population)wdi_electricity_access_pct+0.262024world bank wdi
Safely managed drinking water (% of population)wdi_water_safely_managed_pct+0.362024world bank wdi
Individuals using the internet (%)wdi_internet_users_pct+0.332024world bank wdi
Tax revenue (% of GDP)wdi_tax_revenue_pct_gdp-0.132023world bank wdi

Suppressed dimension

Conversion efficiency

Does spending become outcomes

Not scored because current indicator coverage is below the methodology threshold.

Missing 6 catalogue indicators.

Who benefits

Distributional reach

+0.68

85th percentile

High coverage

100% indicators

Uncertainty shown

CI [+0.54, +0.81]

Audit trail: 4 contributing indicators
IndicatorzYearSource
Gini coefficientwdi_gini+0.992021world bank wdi
Extreme poverty (% under $2.15/day)wdi_extreme_poverty_pct+0.452021world bank wdi
Inequality-adjusted HDIundp_ihdi+0.652023undp hdr
Gender Inequality Indexundp_gii+0.522023undp hdr

Suppressed dimension

Accountability infrastructure

Is power answerable

Not scored because current indicator coverage is below the methodology threshold.

Missing 6 catalogue indicators.

Can the state respond to novelty and shock

Adaptive capacity

-0.12

52th percentile

Moderate coverage

60% indicators

Uncertainty shown

CI [-1.12, +0.89]

Audit trail: 3 contributing indicators
IndicatorzYearSource
R&D expenditure (% of GDP)wdi_rd_expenditure_pct_gdp-0.982024world bank wdi
Central government debt (% of GDP)wdi_central_govt_debt_pct_gdp+0.952023world bank wdi
Internet use (cross-listed with execution capacity)wdi_internet_users_pct+0.332024world bank wdi

Peers

Within-cluster comparison

22 countries in Cluster D. Bars are centred on the cluster mean; the selected country is drawn in black.

Execution capacity

Within-cluster distribution, centred on mean.

rank 14/21

  1. Singapore+1.63
  2. Hong Kong SAR, China+1.17
  3. Macao SAR, China+0.89
  4. Qatar+0.68
  5. United Arab Emirates+0.56
  6. Malaysia+0.36
  7. Oman+0.19
  8. Saudi Arabia+0.16
  9. Bahrain+0.14
  10. Georgia-0.06
  11. Kuwait-0.09
  12. Jordan-0.12
  13. China-0.43
  14. Kazakhstan-0.49
  15. Serbia-0.51
  16. Thailand-0.53
  17. India-0.54
  18. Morocco-0.56
  19. Indonesia-0.84
  20. Philippines-0.95
  21. Rwanda-1.28

Distributional reach

Within-cluster distribution, centred on mean.

rank 2/14

  1. United Arab Emirates+1.31
  2. Kazakhstan+0.68
  3. Serbia+0.57
  4. Qatar+0.18
  5. Georgia+0.15
  6. China+0.15
  7. Thailand+0.05
  8. India-0.06
  9. Malaysia-0.10
  10. Jordan-0.31
  11. Indonesia-0.55
  12. Philippines-0.70
  13. Morocco-1.01
  14. Rwanda-1.96

Adaptive capacity

Within-cluster distribution, centred on mean.

rank 6/13

  1. United Arab Emirates+1.24
  2. Malaysia+0.30
  3. Thailand+0.18
  4. Singapore+0.11
  5. Morocco+0.04
  6. Kazakhstan-0.12
  7. India-0.21
  8. Jordan-0.23
  9. Georgia-0.29
  10. Indonesia-0.31
  11. Rwanda-0.46
  12. Philippines-0.48
  13. Bahrain-0.75

Movement

Five-year trajectory

Indicator-level direction and rate over the most recent five or fewer observations. Rates are normalised against cluster variance so heterogeneous scales can be compared.

5

Improving

0

Declining

20

Stable

Top indicator trajectories over the most recent five-year observation window.
IndicatorDirectionsd / yrConsistencyWindow
wdi_life_expectancyimproving+0.23volatile2020 - 2024
wdi_internet_users_pctimproving+0.11consistent2020 - 2024
wdi_internet_users_pctimproving+0.11consistent2020 - 2024
wgi_control_of_corruptionimproving+0.07volatile2020 - 2024
wgi_government_effectivenessimproving+0.07volatile2020 - 2024
wdi_tax_revenue_pct_gdpstable+0.04volatile2019 - 2023
wdi_measles_immunisationstable+0.04volatile2020 - 2024
wdi_ginistable-0.03consistent2017 - 2021
wdi_rd_expenditure_pct_gdpstable+0.03volatile2020 - 2024
undp_giistable+0.03volatile2019 - 2023

Audit

Raw indicator data

All harmonised indicator series for this country are exposed so the diagnostic can be checked against its inputs.

Raw harmonised indicator data for Kazakhstan.
IndicatorFirstLatestLatest valueObservations
undp_expected_years_schooling1990202314.00934
undp_gdi200020231.00424
undp_gii200020230.18224
undp_gni_per_capita1990202330988.52834
undp_hdi199020230.83734
undp_ihdi201020230.76614
undp_life_expectancy1990202374.40234
undp_mean_years_schooling1990202312.54734
undp_phdi199220230.68732
wdi_central_govt_debt_pct_gdp2010202320.88614
wdi_education_expenditure_pct_gdp199520234.86526
wdi_electricity_access_pct19952024100.00030
wdi_extreme_poverty_pct199320210.00023
wdi_gdp_per_capita_ppp_constant1990202435973.96335
wdi_gini1993202129.20023
wdi_health_expenditure_pct_gdp200020233.76724
wdi_infant_mortality199020247.40035
wdi_internet_users_pct1990202493.39232
wdi_life_expectancy1990202474.53135
wdi_lower_secondary_completion_pct1994202493.98627
wdi_maternal_mortality1990202310.00034
wdi_measles_immunisation1992202493.00033
wdi_population_total1990202420592571.00035
wdi_primary_completion_pct1994202494.40429
wdi_rd_expenditure_pct_gdp199720240.16228
wdi_revenue_pct_gdp1997202316.53722
wdi_sanitation_safely_managed_pctn/an/an/a0
wdi_tax_revenue_pct_gdp1997202311.89222
wdi_urban_population_pct1990202462.07335
wdi_water_safely_managed_pct2000202491.54525
wgi_control_of_corruption19962024-0.07226
wgi_government_effectiveness199620240.07326
wgi_political_stability19962024-0.21126
wgi_regulatory_quality199620240.04426
wgi_rule_of_law19962024-0.40526
wgi_voice_and_accountability19962024-0.91426